Offer in Compromise Preparation Checklist | PitBullTax

An Offer in Compromise case begins well before the application is signed. The practitioner needs a reliable account history, a supported financial picture, and a clear explanation of why the proposed approach fits the taxpayer’s circumstances. When those pieces are collected separately without a review process, missing information often surfaces late in preparation.
A complete case file connects each material figure to evidence and each preparation task to an owner. The following workflow focuses on organizing a financial hardship or collectibility-based review; it is not a substitute for evaluating the specific legal basis of an offer.
Start with eligibility and the purpose of the engagement
The IRS identifies baseline eligibility requirements that include filing required returns, making required estimated payments, and not being in an open bankruptcy proceeding. Employers must also meet applicable federal tax deposit requirements. An offer is not automatically appropriate simply because a taxpayer owes more than they can pay immediately.
Document the issues identified during screening. If a required return is missing, assign responsibility for addressing it. If financial information is incomplete, explain which conclusions must wait. The initial consultation should establish the next investigation step rather than promise acceptance.
Define whether your engagement includes preliminary analysis, application preparation, representation during consideration, or subsequent work. Clear scope helps the client understand why a preliminary estimate may change when additional evidence arrives.
Reconcile the account history
Create a working list of the liabilities being reviewed, including taxpayer identity, tax type, period, and the available account information. Compare that list with notices, prior correspondence, and the client’s understanding of the problem. Record discrepancies as questions requiring investigation.
The file should make it easy to see which records are current and which were obtained earlier. A balance taken from an old notice should not silently become the working figure for a later application. Date the source documents and preserve the assumptions used during preliminary evaluation.
If a client mentions a prior offer, payment arrangement, appeal, or bankruptcy, obtain the relevant records. Those events may affect the procedural and strategic review. Do not treat a brief intake answer as a complete account history.
Build a document request around the applicable forms
Use the current Form 656 booklet and relevant collection information statement instructions to identify the required application materials. The booklet includes Forms 433-A (OIC), 433-B (OIC), and 656, along with instructions and an application checklist. A preliminary screening result does not guarantee acceptance.
Turn the applicable requirements into a client-specific request. Name the document, identify the requested period, explain the preferred delivery method, and state who will answer questions. Mark an item not applicable only after someone has considered it, rather than because the client skipped the question.
Organize received materials into a simple status system: requested, received, reviewed, and follow-up required. Receipt alone should not indicate that an item is ready for use. An incomplete statement or unclear image may still require replacement.
Explain the figures before preparing the final package
Review income, expenses, assets, and liabilities together. For a self-employed taxpayer, ask how the records connect business activity with the household information used in the analysis. Identify transfers or unusual deposits that require explanation rather than counting every unexplained movement as a new income source.
For each significant figure, keep a short workpaper identifying the source, calculation period, and unresolved question. If a balance or valuation changes, update the related workpaper and the documents that use it. That process helps prevent one revised figure from creating conflicting versions across the package.
A hypothetical example illustrates the value of this step: a client initially reports a fixed monthly income, then provides records showing seasonal fluctuations. A useful workpaper explains the period reviewed and why the selected approach reflects the circumstances. A single unsupported monthly number conceals that reasoning.
Prepare the client for the application process
Discuss the selected payment structure and the obligations associated with submitting an offer. Application fees and payments, including exceptions for qualifying low-income individuals, depend on the current rules and selected option. Confirm them from the current instructions before submission.
Give the client a written summary of what remains due from them, what your firm will prepare, and which matters remain uncertain. Make sure they understand that an initial evaluation is not an IRS decision and that additional information may be requested during consideration.
Use a separate readiness check for signatures, supporting records, payment arrangements, and submission instructions. Treat this as a coordinated package rather than a collection of documents that happen to be completed on the same day.
Use software to support consistency
PitBullTax’s Resolution Evaluation tool helps practitioners evaluate potential resolution paths, while its integrated forms and supporting schedules support preparation from client information entered into the platform. Those functions can help organize preparation, but the practitioner still needs to review the supporting facts and the completed output.
During the final review, compare the case analysis with the forms the client will sign. Check that the latest information appears consistently and that explanatory attachments support the statements they accompany.
Keep a submission and follow-up record
Preserve the final signed materials, applicable submission evidence, payment documentation, and a dated case note. Record who will monitor for acknowledgments and requests for information. When correspondence arrives, assign a response task and track it to completion.
Avoid closing preparation tasks by simply marking the application sent. The operational handoff should identify who owns the next stage and what will trigger the next review.
Frequently asked questions
Does completing the forms establish that an offer is appropriate?
No. Forms organize the application. Suitability depends on the taxpayer’s circumstances, the applicable offer basis, and current IRS requirements.
Should the same document request go to every client?
Use a standard starting list, then tailor it to the relevant forms, entity, financial circumstances, and unresolved issues.
What should happen when information changes before submission?
Identify the affected calculations and documents, update them consistently, and repeat the relevant review before obtaining final approval.
Organize your next OIC case
Explore Resolution Evaluation and schedule a PitBullTax demo to review how the tools can support your firm’s preparation process.
Sources
[1] IRS — Offer in Compromise: https://www.irs.gov/payments/offer-in-compromise
[2] IRS — Form 656 Booklet and application checklist: https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f656b.pdf
[3] PitBullTax — Resolution Evaluation: https://www.pitbulltax.com/page/resolution-evaluation.html
[4] PitBullTax — Software Features: https://www.pitbulltax.com/page/software.html

